Fuel Card Types & Options: Complete Guide (2025)

Fleet managers today face an overwhelming array of fleet fuel cards, each promising savings and security benefits. With fuel costs accounting for up to 60% of fleet operating expenses, selecting the right fuel card can have a significant impact on your bottom line. This comprehensive guide breaks down the five main types of fuel cards, their unique features, and how to select the optimal solution for your specific business needs.

Quick Summary

• Fleet fuel cards offer the highest per-gallon discounts (up to 40¢) but work only within specific networks.
• Universal fuel cards provide maximum flexibility with 95%+ gas station acceptance and moderate savings (3-8¢ per gallon)
• Branded fuel cards offer strong fuel discounts (5-15¢ per gallon) at select petroleum brands, including Shell and ExxonMobil.
• Prepaid fuel cards eliminate credit requirements and provide absolute spending controls through a pre-loaded balance.
• Cardlock fuel cards offer the lowest fuel costs (up to 35¢ per gallon savings) at an unmanned commercial station.
• Modern fleet fuel cards include advanced fraud protection, real-time monitoring, and integrated fleet management capabilities.

{{CTA}}

What are the Different Types of Fuel Cards?

The fuel card market offers five distinct categories of payment solutions, each engineered to serve specific operational requirements and business models. Understanding these fundamental differences helps fleet managers select cards that align with their geographic coverage needs, spending volumes, and operational complexity levels.

The global fuel card market reached $886.5 billion in 2025 and is projected to expand to $595.9 billion by 2032, reflecting the growing recognition of these specialized payment tools as essential business assets. This rapid growth stems from their evolution beyond simple payment processing to comprehensive fleet management platforms that provide cost savings, fraud protection, and operational insights.

1. Fleet Fuel Cards

Features

Fleet fuel cards operate on specialized closed-loop networks designed exclusively for commercial transportation operations. These cards provide access to truck stops, travel centers, and fueling stations with high-volume pumps and amenities specifically designed for large vehicles and professional drivers.

Best Suited Industries/Businesses

• Long-haul trucking companies
• Freight and logistics operations
• Construction companies with heavy equipment
• Delivery services with large vehicle fleets

Pros

• Commercial-focused amenities: Access to truck washes, scales, and driver facilities
• Detailed reporting: Comprehensive transaction data, including odometer readings and driver information
• Volume-based rebates: Additional savings for high-volume purchasers
• Industry-specific purchase controls: Restrictions tailored for commercial operations

Cons

• Limited geographic coverage: Primarily concentrated in major transportation corridors
• Network restrictions: Cannot be used at all gas stations
• Higher complexity: Requires training for proper usage and compliance
• Monthly fees: Often include account maintenance charges

Ready to explore fleet fuel card options? Get started with AtoB to see how our fleet-focused solution can reduce your fuel costs by up to 45¢ per gallon.

2. Universal Fuel Cards

Features

Universal fuel cards operate on major payment networks, such as Visa or Mastercard, providing acceptance at virtually any fuel station nationwide. These cards combine the flexibility of credit cards with the specialized spending controls and reporting capabilities designed for fleet operations.

Best Suited Industries/Businesses

• Service companies with unpredictable routes
• Emergency response fleets
• Sales teams covering large territories
• Multi-state delivery operations

Pros

• Maximum flexibility: Accepted at 95%+ of fuel stations nationwide
• No network limitations: Drivers can purchase fuel anywhere without restrictions
• Simplified training: Familiar credit card-style interface
• Comprehensive coverage: Works in rural and urban areas equally well
• Emergency accessibility: Never stranded due to network limitations

Cons

• Lower discount rates: Typically, 3-8¢ per gallon savings
• Higher transaction fees: May include per-transaction charges
• Less specialized reporting: Limited commercial fleet-specific data
• Reduced negotiating power: Cannot leverage network exclusivity

The Voyager fleet card demonstrates market leadership with acceptance at over 320,000 locations representing 97% of gas stations nationwide, making it the preferred choice for fleets requiring maximum operational flexibility [5].

3. Branded Fuel Cards

Features

Branded fuel cards are issued directly by major petroleum companies, including Shell, ExxonMobil, BP, and Chevron. These cards provide exclusive access to brand-specific discount programs, promotional offers, and fuel rewards that can deliver substantial savings for fleets with predictable fueling patterns.

Best Suited Industries/Businesses

• Local delivery companies with established routes
• Government fleets with preferred vendor contracts
• Businesses operating near concentrated brand locations
• Companies prioritizing brand loyalty relationships

Pros

• Strong brand discounts: 5-15¢ per gallon savings at participating locations
• Loyalty program benefits: Access to exclusive promotions and rewards
• Predictable savings: Consistent discount rates at brand locations
• No network fees: Often eliminates out-of-network transaction charges
• Maintenance partnerships: Integration with brand-affiliated service centers

Cons

• Geographic limitations: Restricted to specific brand station locations
• Route dependency: Less effective for unpredictable routing
• Limited flexibility: Cannot access competitor stations without penalties
• Regional variations: Brand density varies significantly by geographic area

The Shell card fuel rewards program exemplifies the benefits of branded fuel cards, offering tiered discounts of 3¢ per gallon for Silver status, 5¢ for Gold status, and 10¢ for Platinum status members, based on monthly purchase volumes [3].

4. Prepaid Fuel Cards

Features

A prepaid fuel card functions like a prepaid gift card, requiring advance funding before fuel purchases can be authorized. This model eliminates credit requirements while providing absolute spending controls through predetermined balance limits.

Best Suited Industries/Businesses

• Seasonal businesses with variable operations
• New companies without an established credit history
• Small businesses require strict budget control
• Operations with high employee turnover

Pros

• No credit requirements: Approval without credit checks or financial documentation
• Absolute spending controls: Cannot exceed pre-loaded balance amounts
• Eliminated overspending risk: No potential for unexpected charges or fees
• Immediate implementation: Setup typically completed within minutes
• Simplified accounting: Prepaid expenses eliminate complex billing reconciliation

Cons

• Advance funding requirement: Ties up cash flow in card balances
• Limited flexibility: Cannot exceed the balance, even for legitimate business needs
• Reload requirements: Requires ongoing balance management and monitoring
• Potential stranding: Insufficient balance can leave drivers unable to purchase fuel

RoadFlex prepaid fuel cards exemplify the evolution of this market segment, offering universal acceptance without credit requirements while eliminating many traditional fees that can cost small businesses over $1,700 per month [3].

Looking for budget control without credit requirements? Learn more about AtoB's flexible payment options that accommodate diverse business needs.

5. Cardlock Fuel Cards

Features

Cardlock fuel cards offer access to unmanned commercial fueling stations equipped with high-volume pumps, specifically designed for fleet operations. These service stations operate on cost-plus pricing structures that eliminate retail markup, delivering wholesale-level fuel pricing to qualified commercial customers.

Best Suited Industries/Businesses

• Western U.S. regional transportation companies
• High-volume fleet operations
• Businesses prioritizing the lowest possible fuel costs
• Operations with experienced truck drivers

Pros

• Lowest fuel costs: Up to 35¢ per gallon savings through cost-plus pricing
• Commercial infrastructure: High-capacity pumps designed for large vehicles
• Wholesale pricing: Direct access to rack rate pricing without retail markup
• Efficient operations: Unstaffed facilities eliminate service delays
• Volume incentives: Greater savings for higher-volume operations

Cons

• Geographic concentration: Primarily limited to the Western United States
• Limited amenities: They typically lack convenience stores and driver facilities
• Learning curve: Requires driver training for unstaffed operation procedures
• Network fragmentation: Different cardlock brands are not interchangeable

CFN cardlock cards offer access to approximately 3,000 discount locations, providing an estimated savings of 35¢ per gallon, while maintaining universal card acceptance at over 65,000 gas stations nationwide for operational flexibility.

{{CTA}}

6 Benefits of Fuel Cards You Should Know

1. Discounts & Savings

Modern fleet fuel cards deliver immediate per-gallon discounts ranging from 3¢ for universal cards to 45¢ for specialized truck stop networks. Volume-based rebate programs can provide additional savings, with businesses typically achieving over $ 2,000 in annual savings per vehicle through strategic card selection and usage optimization.

2. Spending Controls

Advanced spending controls enable fleet managers to establish daily spending limits, restrict purchase categories, implement time-based restrictions, and require driver authentication for fuel transactions. These controls prevent unauthorized employee spending while maintaining operational flexibility for legitimate business needs.

3. Security Protection

Comprehensive fraud protection includes EMV chip technology, One-Time PIN authentication, real-time transaction monitoring, and GPS verification systems. These multi-layered security measures have become essential as fleet card fraud represents a significant portion of the $12.5 billion in annual payment fraud losses.

4. Better Visibility & Transparency

Detailed fuel transactions reporting provides comprehensive insights into fuel consumption patterns, driver performance, and operational efficiency metrics. Real-time monitoring capabilities enable immediate identification of unusual spending patterns or fraudulent transactions.

5. Ease of Use

Modern fuel cards offer user-friendly interfaces, mobile applications for locating fuel stations and viewing fuel prices, and streamlined transaction procedures that require minimal driver training. Universal card acceptance eliminates the complexity of network-specific usage requirements.

6. Streamline Fleet Administration & Documentation

Automated expense tracking eliminates the need for manual receipt collection and data entry. Integration with fleet management software provides seamless expense categorization and financial reporting, while detailed transaction records satisfy audit and tax reporting requirements.

What Factors Should You Consider When Choosing a Fuel Card?

Application and Usage

Evaluate your business fleet size, operational patterns, and geographic coverage requirements to determine optimal card features. Small fleets (1-4 vehicles) typically benefit from universal cards, while larger trucking companies may justify specialized fleet card programs with higher discount rates.

Budgeting and Control

Consider spending control requirements, driver accountability needs, and financial management capabilities. Prepaid fuel cards provide absolute budget control, while credit and debit card systems offer operational flexibility with comprehensive monitoring capabilities.

Coverage & Network Acceptance

Analyze route patterns and geographic operational requirements to ensure adequate station coverage. Universal fuel cards offer maximum flexibility, while specialized networks provide fuel discounts in exchange for adhering to geographic limitations at specific gas stations.

Telematics Integration

Evaluate integration capabilities with existing fleet management systems, GPS tracking platforms, and accounting software. Advanced integration provides comprehensive operational insights and automated administrative processes.

Security Features

Assess fraud protection requirements, transaction monitoring needs, and risk tolerance levels to ensure effective protection against fraud. Multi-layered security systems, including EMV chips and OTP technology, provide comprehensive protection against unauthorized usage.

Ready to find the perfect fuel card match? Contact AtoB for personalized recommendations based on your specific fleet requirements.

Which Type of Fuel Card Is Best for Your Needs?

The optimal fuel card provider selection depends on balancing operational requirements, cost considerations, and administrative capabilities:

• Choose fleet cards for maximum savings with high-volume trucking operations
• Select universal cards for operational flexibility across diverse geographic areas
• Opt for branded cards when route patterns align with shell stations or other specific petroleum brand locations
• Consider prepaid cards for credit-independent operations requiring strict budget control
• Evaluate cardlock cards for Western U.S. operations, prioritizing the lowest possible fuel costs

FAQs

Are fuel cards worth having?

Yes, fleet fuel cards typically deliver annual savings of around $2,000 or more per vehicle through fuel discounts, improved operational efficiency, and reduced administrative costs. The comprehensive expense tracking and fraud protection capabilities offer additional value beyond direct savings on diesel fuel and unleaded gas.

What are the risks of fuel credit cards?

Primary risks include potential exposure to fraud, overspending without proper purchase controls, and dependency on specific networks. Modern security measures, including EMV chips and real-time monitoring, significantly reduce these risks when properly implemented.

What credit score is needed for a fuel card?

Credit requirements vary by fuel card provider and card type. Traditional fleet cards often require a good credit history (a score of 650 or higher), whereas prepaid options eliminate credit requirements. Many providers offer approval without personal guarantees for established businesses.

Find the Right Fuel Card Type for Your Business

Selecting the best fleet fuel card requires careful analysis of your operational patterns, geographic requirements, and cost optimization priorities. Whether you need the maximum flexibility of universal cards or the specialized savings of fleet-specific networks, the right fuel card can deliver substantial operational benefits while protecting against fraud and unauthorized fuel spending.

The evolution of fleet management fuel cards technology continues to create new opportunities to save money and improve operational efficiency. By understanding the unique advantages of each card type and matching them to your specific business requirements, you can implement fuel card programs that deliver measurable bottom-line improvements while simplifying fleet expense management.

Transform your fleet fuel management with AtoB's comprehensive solution. Get started today and discover how our universal fuel card can deliver competitive savings with maximum operational flexibility.

{{CTA}}

Citations:

[1] https://www.atob.com/blog/fuel-card-companies-comparison
[2] https://www.wexinc.com/resources/blog/how-to-combat-fuel-theft-and-what-to-do-if-it-happens/
[3] https://www.roadflex.com/prefunded
[4] https://www.pfleet.com/blog/best-universal-fuel-cards
[5] https://cnrgfleet.com/the-5-best-business-fuel-cards-for-fleet-management-in-2025-complete-comparison-guide/